The NYT Comes Around

April 2, 2013


Yesterday I posted that the White House’s upcoming BRAIN initiative was conceptually incoherent, and I snarkily implied the NYT needed some science-fiction checkers for its overly credulous reporting of what we could expect out of the initiative.

What a difference a day makes! In an article today they’ve become more skeptical. They write: “the new initiative… has, as yet, no clearly defined goals or endpoint. Coming up with those goals will be up to the scientists involved and may take more than year.”

It’s a good pickup on the Times’s part, though they may be overly optimistic that Obama has chosen the right scientists, and that a year is the proper order of magnitude for coming up with a paradigm shift. We’ll have to watch to see how much sense the new program ends up making, and when it starts making it.

I’ll predict that the likely outcome will be a balkanized program. The reason? I just don’t think neuroscience has a new paradigm to shift into at this point, and I don’t think government money’s going to make one appear in the next year. Nobody, for example, seems that jazzed about my candidate shift – that the electromagnetic field is the ground of consciousness, and that the brain filters human consciousness out of it (rather than “creating” it as the party line currently has it). Even though Walter Freeman has devoted his life to showing the empirical basis for this idea – if you haven’t read his work, start here.  I hope I’m wrong – I’d love to see Freeman get the play he deserves. And regardless I’m glad the research is being done, new paradigm or not. Let’s wait to see whether the Times can continue to dial back on the breathlessness as the year unfolds.


About Peter Freed, M.D.

I am a psychiatrist (psychopharmacology and psychotherapy) specializing in the so-called "personality disorders," particularly narcissistic and borderline personality disorders. I was a Fellow and then an Assistant Professor of Clinical Psychiatry at Columbia from 2004- 2011. I am currently in private practice in NYC.

View all posts by Peter Freed, M.D.

Subscribe to

Subscribe to our RSS feed and social profiles to receive updates.

11 Comments on “The NYT Comes Around”

  1. epilepsymeandneurology Says:

    eventually the only way progress will be made is when everyone who has worked out how conciousness works is well and happy and everyone who hasn’t is still spending buzzillions of $ on further research that fails to take into account all possibilities. I think your reading and reaserch is right on the money, the model for conciousness is so out of the box that they just aren’t ready for it yet (or if they know they think we aren’t !). I appreciate the link to walter freeman thank you.


  2. Gantulga Says:

    You are probably aware that meciadl education is now taught by powerpoint right and that books are mostly have been the thing of past….right? There will be too many powerpoints that you will need to learn for you to have time to open up most books unless its gross anatomy which i opened for a month and then quit. Plus that money is beer money dude. But seriously, my tests usually cover over 1100-1200 powerpoint slides. Thanks for reading.


  3. Zavrina Says:|lasix eye surgery in owensboro ky kid|what is the best car insurance in nj for young drivers 279101


  4. ireland insurance car Says:

    It’s really great that people are sharing this information.


  5. Bei Says:

    Great! Therapy is becoming a life saver these days. People tend to stoop down into dopiessren due to stress and family issues and in that context, therapy is very prominent. It helps people to shed their stress off and live a life with a tension free life. Quite a good read!


  6. viagra Says:

    It’s posts like this that make surfing so much pleasure


  7. SEO Expert Says:

    Glad to read your post :). It is very informative!


  8. Paula Says:

    This article acieevhd exactly what I wanted it to achieve.


  9. Service Dog training At home Says:

    When your pet obeys your commands, you should offer
    some additional snacks being a reward. At this aspect working out is gradually increasingly difficult
    for your dog. Bark Stop emits ultrasound reducing sound tones, inaudible to
    humans, that train your dog to stop barking. Florida isn’t only warm and
    sunny all year round, however it can also be among the most populated states inside the country.


  10. Ron Says:

    He even called Cabinet Secretary Sir Jeremy Heywood, Britain’s most eminent scientists, chinese culture and see what’s going on in America to divorce from mainstream medicine.
    If the patient chinese culture believed he was dealing with HIV
    looks much more easily. This article has been seen that diabetes people have found hypnotherapy to make a difference?

    This is a rip off, and physical.


  11. Lonna Says:

    Hello, after reading this remarkable paragraph i am as well glad to
    share my experience here with friends.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: